With season-long injuries a much lesser concern, can scary-health guys like Rob Gronkowski climb to the top of weekly rankings?
Peyton Manning is the consensus No. 1 quarterback for the season to come, but if you wanted to argue for Drew Brees or Aaron Rodgers, you could make the point without being crazy. The same goes for Calvin Johnson at wide receiver, where Demaryius Thomas has an argument for the top. Jamaal Charles, Adrian Peterson, LeSean McCoy and even Matt Forte could go No. 1 at running back.
At tight end, though, no one had any real debate for the top spot in the season rankings. It was Jimmy Graham, and everyone agreed. He was the most talented tight end by a little, but the most reliable one by a lot, and that made the difference.
On a weekly basis, though, the argument can be more interesting. Because the argument against Julius Thomas and (primarily) Rob Gronkowski on a season-long basis is injuries. In your fantasy draft, you couldn't reasonably draft Gronkowski with any real expectation of him playing 16 games. Graham gets banged up occasionally, but Gronkowski gets banged up as a matter of course.
But none of that matters in weekly rankings. Not really. When we sit down early in the week to do rankings, and Rob Gronkowski is healthy, there's no reason he can't/shouldn't rank ahead of Graham. Because as long as he's healthy, Gronkowski (and yes, Julius Thomas) can be that No. 1 tight end that he just can't be seen as over 17 weeks.
Below are the Week 1 tight end rankings, both consensus and from our individual rankers. Before that is a glance at a few key guys.
Jimmy Graham (Consensus Rank: No. 1) - Yes, after all the above, Graham still came in No. 1 in our consensus ranks, and he was unanimous among the individual rankers as well. The above point was more a general season thought. Anyway, Graham, off a legendary season, gets to start his 2014 against an Atlanta Falcons team that does not boast a strong defense. Enjoy that.
Jordan Reed (Consensus Rank: No. 7) - From that injury perspective, Reed is sort of the poor man's Gronkowski; he was great last year when he was on the field, but persistent concussion issues limited his play. But again, as long as he plays, there's no reason not to capitalize.
Antonio Gates and Ladarius Green (Consensus Ranks: Gates No. 12, Green No. 15) - The two Chargers tight ends are both fantasy-relevant, if not fantasy powerhouses. Gates is on his way out, career-wise, while Green is on the opposite end. But either could have strong seasons, and if all goes well for the Chargers, both could.
Tim Wright (Consensus Rank: No. 25) - Every one of our rankers listed the new Patriot, and none had him above 19th. There is a wide range of possible outcomes for Wright, who finished 14th at the position last year in Tampa Bay despite barely being a factor early in the season. If he can grow into the Aaron Hernandez-type role in New England, he could be a fantasy season-maker. But the downside is a midseason release. Early in the season, the best bet on Wright is to pick him up and watch, not use him in fantasy.
Consensus Writer Rankings
Rank | Player | Team | Opponent |
1 | Jimmy Graham | New Orleans | at Atlanta |
2 | Julius Thomas | Denver | Indianapolis |
3 | Rob Gronkowski | New England | at Miami |
4 | Vernon Davis | San Francisco | at Dallas |
5 | Jordan Cameron | Cleveland | at Pittsburgh |
6 | Jason Witten | Dallas | San Francisco |
7 | Jordan Reed | Washington | at Houston |
8 | Greg Olsen | Carolina | at Tampa Bay |
9 | Dennis Pitta | Baltimore | Cincinnati |
10 | Zach Ertz | Philadelphia | Jacksonville |
11 | Kyle Rudolph | Minnesota | at St. Louis |
12 | Antonio Gates | San Diego | at Arizona |
13 | Martellus Bennett | Chicago | Buffalo |
14 | Charles Clay | Miami | New England |
15 | Ladarius Green | San Diego | at Arizona |
16 | Heath Miller | Pittsburgh | Cleveland |
17 | Travis Kelce | Kansas City | Tennessee |
18 | Dwayne Allen | Indianapolis | at Denver |
19 | Delanie Walker | Tennessee | at Kansas City |
20 | Garrett Graham | Houston | Washington |
21 | Coby Fleener | Indianapolis | at Denver |
22 | Jared Cook | St. Louis | Minnesota |
23 | Tyler Eifert | Cincinnati | at Baltimore |
24 | Eric Ebron | Detroit | NY Giants |
25 | Tim Wright | New England | at Miami |
Individual Writer Rankings
Rank | Daniel Kelley | Dan Ciarrocchi | John Daigle | Scott Kaliska |
1 | Jimmy Graham | Jimmy Graham | Jimmy Graham | Jimmy Graham |
2 | Rob Gronkowski | Julius Thomas | Julius Thomas | Julius Thomas |
3 | Julius Thomas | Rob Gronkowski | Zach Ertz | Rob Gronkowski |
4 | Vernon Davis | Jordan Cameron | Vernon Davis | Jordan Cameron |
5 | Jordan Cameron | Vernon Davis | Jordan Cameron | Vernon Davis |
6 | Jason Witten | Jason Witten | Kyle Rudolph | Greg Olsen |
7 | Jordan Reed | Jordan Reed | Antonio Gates | Jason Witten |
8 | Dennis Pitta | Dennis Pitta | Rob Gronkowski | Jordan Reed |
9 | Greg Olsen | Greg Olsen | Greg Olsen | Dennis Pitta |
10 | Antonio Gates | Kyle Rudolph | Jordan Reed | Kyle Rudolph |
11 | Ladarius Green | Zach Ertz | Dennis Pitta | Zach Ertz |
12 | Charles Clay | Martellus Bennett | Jason Witten | Martellus Bennett |
13 | Zach Ertz | Antonio Gates | Travis Kelce | Charles Clay |
14 | Coby Fleener | Charles Clay | Martellus Bennett | Heath Miller |
15 | Kyle Rudolph | Heath Miller | Dwayne Allen | Antonio Gates |
16 | Eric Ebron | Ladarius Green | Richard Rodgers | Ladarius Green |
17 | Martellus Bennett | Garrett Graham | Heath Miller | Travis Kelce |
18 | Travis Kelce | Dwayne Allen | Charles Clay | Delanie Walker |
19 | Marcedes Lewis | Delanie Walker | Tim Wright | Dwayne Allen |
20 | Tyler Eifert | Tyler Eifert | Ladarius Green | Garrett Graham |
21 | Delanie Walker | Jared Cook | Delanie Walker | Jared Cook |
22 | Heath Miller | Travis Kelce | Jared Cook | Tyler Eifert |
23 | Jared Cook | Tim Wright | Garrett Graham | Eric Ebron |
24 | Garrett Graham | Coby Fleener | Scott Chandler | Coby Fleener |
25 | Tim Wright | Eric Ebron | Coby Fleener | Tim Wright |
from SBNation.com - All Posts http://ift.tt/1qomHfr
0 commentaires:
Enregistrer un commentaire